top of page
Soft textured sprinkle background.jpg

Online Ordering

You can order online! Browse our menu items and choose what you’d like to order from us.

Accepting Orders
Pickup time: Oct 24, 8:00 AM - 9:00 AM
Pickup Address: Lake Mills, IA 50450

Custom Cakes

Whether you are celebrating your birthday, baptism, retirement, or just because! We offer our cakes in Vanilla, Chocolate, Lemon, Carrot, Strawberry, Red Velvet, and Marble Opt in for a tasty filling! We offer fresh strawberry, raspberry, lemon. blueberry, cherry, chocolate cream, vanilla cream, and German chocolate! Our frostings are classic American buttercream, cream cheese, or a lighter Italian meringue buttercream.

Sheet Cakes

1/8 Sheet

Serves 6 to 8 people

$25.00

1/4 Sheet

Serves 16-24

$40.00

1/2 Sheet

Serves 32-48

$60.00

Heart Cakes

Single Layer

8'' Shaped cake. Serves 8-10

$20.00

Double Layer

Serves 12 to 18

$40.00

Round Cakes

6" Single Layer

Serves 2 to 4

$20.00

6" Double Layer

Serves 6 to 8

$30.00

8" Single Layer

Serves 6-10

$30.00

8" Double Layer

Serves 14-18

$40.00

10" Single Layer

Serves 12-16

$30.00

10" Double Layer

Serves 26-28

$60.00

Cupcakes

Regular

Dreamy Vanilla

A dreamy combination of moist vanilla cake with a not-too-sweet vanilla buttercream frosting.

$3.00

Death By Chocolate

Decadent chocolate cake topped with chocolate buttercream. Drizzled with chocolate ganache and garnished with a Hershey's bar

$3.00

Birthday Confetti

Our vanilla cake swirled with bright sprinkles. Topped with vanilla buttercream and of course, more sprinkles!

$3.00

Luscious Lemon

Sweet and tart lemon cake topped with more delightful lemon buttercream. Garnished with candied lemon.

$3.00

Almond Wedding Cake

Our classic vanilla cake slightly flavored with almond. Topped beautifully with almond buttercream and garnished with almonds.

$3.00

Mocha Madness

Rich and flavorful chocolate cake with just a hint of mocha. Topped with espresso buttercream and garnished with a drizzle of chocolate ganache and a chocolate covered espresso bean

$3.00

Red Velvet

Lightly chocolatey with just a hint of cinnamon. Topped with a swirl of cream cheese icing and a chocolate heart!

$3.00

Tuxedo

The best of both worlds! Chocolate and vanilla cake marbled together then topped with a swirl of chocolate and vanilla buttercream.

$3.00

Strawberry Shortcake

Vanilla cupcake topped with strawberry buttercream frosting and filled with fresh strawberry compote

$3.00

Edible Cookie Dough

A vanilla cupcake swirled with chocolate chips and topped with edible cookie dough. Garnished with a mini chocolate chip cookie

$3.00

Salted Caramel

One of our most popular flavors! Our decadent chocolate cake filled with from-scratch salted caramel. Topped with salted caramel buttercream and garnished with a drizzle of chocolate ganache and flakey sea salt

$3.00

Peanut Butter Cup

Our most popular flavor! Chocolate cake topped with sweet and salty peanut butter buttercream. Garnished with chocolate ganache and a peanut butter cup!

$3.00

Oreo Overload

Chocolate cupcake with a hidden Oreo baked inside. Topped with Oreo buttercream and another Oreo!

$3.00

Berries 'n' Cream

Vanilla cupcake filled with a mix berry compote. Topped with vanilla buttercream and garnished with fresh berries.

$3.00

Nutty Nutella

Chocolate cupcake filled with Nutella. Topped with Nutella buttercream and crushed hazlenuts.

$3.00

Lemon Blueberry

Bright and summery! Lemon cupcake dotted with fresh blueberries. Topped with lemon buttercream and garnished with candied lemon and a blueberry!

$3.00

Carrot Cake

Warmly spiced cake filled with carrots, raisins, and walnuts. Topped with cream cheese icing.

$3.00

Espresso Addict

Coffee lovers to the extreme! Espresso flavored cupcake filled with our creamy espresso pastry cream. Topped with espresso buttercream and a chocolate espresso bean

$3.00

Earl Grey

Moist Earl Grey tea flavored cake filled with a blackberry curd. Topped with a swirl of Earl Grey buttercream and fresh blackberries!

$3.00

Minis

Our mini cupcakes are by the dozen only. You may choose up to 3 flavors. Options include Vanilla, Chocolate, Peanut Butter, Lemon, Strawberry, Almond, Confetti, and Red Velvet.

Dozen

$12.00

Custom Cupcakes

From child's themed birthdays to sweet baby showers, gorgeous bouquets of flowers, and everything in between! We would love to work with you to find that perfect fit for your party! Message us to create your ideal cupcake!

Custom Design

Depending on the complexity of your design prices can vary

$4.00

Breads and Breakfast

Breads

Brioche Style Sandwich

Enriched with eggs this loaf is as rich and flavor as it is soft!

$7.00

Apple Cinnamon Swirl

$8.00

Cinnamon Swirl

$8.00

Banana

$8.00

Hamburger Buns

Per Dozen

$12.00

Dinner Rolls

6ct

$8.00

Sesame Artisan Loaf

A vegan offering. A crusty loaf rolled in sesame seeds with a soft and chewy inside.

$8.00

Artisan Loaf

Crusty outside, chewy inside. Similar in taste between an Italian bread and sourdough.

$8.00

Scones

Blueberry

Each

$3.00

Strawberry

Each

$3.00

Pumpkin Spice

Each

$3.00

Jumbo Muffins

Blueberry Crumble

$4.00

Coffee Cake

$4.00

Pumpkin Spice

$4.00

Lemon Poppyseed

$4.00

Double Chocolate

$4.00

Cinnamon Rolls

Cream Cheese Iced 4ct

$16.00

White Iced 4ct

$12.00

Bagels

Perfect for piling filings to make sandwiches or toasted with a pat of butter. These come in 4ct.

Plain

Classic chewy outside and soft inside

$8.00

Everything Seasoning

Our plain bagel rolled in everything bagel seasoning

$8.00

Cinnamon Raisin

A sweeter take on our bagels. Cinnamon swirls dotted with raisins.

$8.00

Blueberry

Swirled with fresh blueberries

$8.00

Rainbow

Our plain bagel with a twist! Vibrant swirls of color are packed into these beauties!

$10.00

Sweet Treats

Cookies

A delightful assortment of flavorful options. Cookies are sold by the dozen

Chocolate Chip

A classic favorite! Gooey and stuffed with chocolate chips.

$12.00

Peanut Butter

Chewy and full of peanut butter flavor!

$12.00

White Chocolate Macadamia Nut

Vanilla cookie dough stuffed with white chocolate chips and macadamia nuts

$12.00

Monster

Peanut butter cookie with oats, chocolate chips, AND M&M's

$12.00

M&M

Classic cookie dough loaded with M&M candies.

$12.00

Lemon Crinkle

Delightful lemon flavored cookie dough rolled in powdered sugar

$12.00

Sugar

Vanilla cookie dough with just a hint of lemon then rolled in sugar

$12.00

Snickerdoodle

A cinnamon-y delight. A cinnamon cookie rolled in cinnamon sugar.

$12.00

Ginger Molasses

The best of both worlds! Zing-y ginger and sweet molasses cookie rolled in cinnamon sugar.

$12.00

Double Chocolate Chip

Chocolate lovers rejoice! Chocolatey cookie loaded with chocolate chips

$12.00

Oatmeal

A classic oatmeal cookie

$12.00

Oatmeal Raisin

Our delicious oatmeal cookie loaded with raisins

$12.00

Brownies

Delicious and fudge-y! These come in 6ct packs

Uniced

$6.00

Fudge Iced

$8.00

Fudge with Sprinkles

$8.00

Fudge with Walnuts

$8.00

Peach and Mint Tiered Cake
Cinnamon Swirl Bread
Chocolate floral cupcakes

Sweet Nessie's Cottage Bakery powered by Wix

bottom of page